Annals of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Surgery

Indexed in /covered by CAS, KoreaScience & DOI/Crossref:eISSN 2508-5859   pISSN 2508-5778

Table. 3.

Table. 3.

Comparison of various studies of pancreatico-gastrostomy

Authors PG technique No. POPF % DGE Bile leak % Blood loss Operative time Hospital stay Time to drain removal Time to oral feed Wound complication Haemorrhage Morbidity Mortality
Fang et al. 200711 Invagination in to posterior without duct to mucosa 189 3.7% 11.1% 891 +/−556 (100-4500) 6.7 +/−1.2 (4-11) 26.1 +/−13.6 (4-106) NR NR 6.9% NR 39.9% 2.1%
Aranah et al. 200312 Invagination in to posterior without duct to mucosa 171 16% 2% NR 1085/−668 6.8/−0.96 11.2 +/−5.3 NR NR 6% NR NR 0%
El Nakeeb et al. 201413 Two layered with 3 cm posterior gastrostomy 45 A=6.6
B=6.6
C=8.8 (22.2)
9% 13.5 400 (100-3000) 300 (210-420) 9 (4-34) 9 (4-34) 6 (4-30) 4.4% 2.2% 46.6% 8.8%
Yeo et al. 199514 Two layered with 3 cm posterior gastrostomy 73 12% 22% 1% 964 +/−118 7.4 +/−0.2 17.1 +/−1.6 NR NR 19% NR 49% NR
Yap et al. 201815 Invagination in to posterior gastrotomy with internal stent 47 A=24%
B=0%
C=0%
4.25% 2.12% 563.8 (200-500) 351 (243-553) 12 (6-35) NR NR 2.12% NR 44.68% 4.25%
Fernández-Cruz et al. 200816 Gastric partition 53 A=1
B=2
C=0
4% 0% 965 +/−786 300 +/−50 12 +/−2 NR NR 8% 23% 0%
Keck et al. 201617 NR 171 B/C 20% 37% NR 500 (0-3000) 332 (165-600) 15 (5-208) NR NR 12% 21% NR 6%
Duffas et al. 200518 NR 81 165 16% 6.5 (4-15) 20 (1-95) NR NR 2% 16% 45.6% 12%
Topal and Fieuws 201319 Invagination in to posterior gastrotomy 162 20.4% 15% NR NR NR 19 (14-25) NR NR NR 13% NR 3%
Wellner et al. 201220 Invagination posterior gastrotomy, no duct to mucosa, through anterior gastrotomy 59 B/C 10% 27% NR NR 404 (280-629) 15 (7-135) NR NR NR 10% NR 2%
Figueras et al. 201321 Invagination in to posterior gastrotomy 65 A=5%
B=3%
C=8%
29% 20% 812.5 (1-4000) 300 (235-620) 12 (1-52) 6 (0-30) NR NR 20% 63% 5%
Payne and Pain 200610 Duct to mucosa over internal stent 100 0% 10% 4% 1020 (400-3200) 325 (240-490) 18 (8-35) 4 NR NR 4% 18%a 1%
Bassi 200522 Invagination in to posterior gastrotomy 69 13% 3% 0% NR NR 14.2 NR NR NR NR 29% 0%
Present Series Duct to mucosa without stent 35 A-28.5%
B-8.5%
C-2.8%
A-31.5%
B-60%
C-8.5%
2.8% 365 (50-3000) 444 (240-666) 12.9 (7-26) 9 (6-22) 9 (5-19) 5.6% 2.8% 25.71% 2.8%

aMajor Morbidity

POPF, post operative pancreatic fistula; DGE, delayed gastric emptying, NR, not reported

Ann Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg 2021;25:251-8 https://doi.org/10.14701/ahbps.2021.25.2.251
© 2021 Ann Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg